Where to Eat in St. Augustine Florida

Where to Eat in St. Augustine Florida

This article may contain affiliate links. Clicking on or purchasing products we recommend through a link may earn a small commission. Read our disclosure and privacy policy page for details.

As there was no shortage of amazing places to eat during our vacation in St. Augustine, I thought I would run through some of the places we visited during our trip. There are so many more great places but here are my suggestions on where to eat in St. Augustine Florida. Warning this post is filled with mouthwatering food shots!

Overview of appetizers on table at Michael's Tasting Room St. Augustine Florida

Restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida

Michael’s Tasting Room

This family-run restaurant is perfect for casual, fine-dining. The menu changes seasonally as its food ingredients are sourced locally. The restaurant features Latin-inspired cuisine paired with a collection of great wines and craft beers.

dinner at Michael's Tasting room St. Augustine

From the very first sip of peach sangria, I was hooked. However, they have the most extensive wine cellar available, so I feel a bit bad I didn’t indulge in wine. We started our meal with some pretty and delicious appetizers.

lamb and sausage dish served at Michael's Tasting Room in St. Augustine Florida

The hearty main dishes came, and I knew there would be no room for dessert. This is a restaurant you don’t want to miss, so be sure to make a reservation. For more information visit Michael’s Tasting Room website here.

Appetizer dish at Michaels Restaurant in St. Augustine Florida. One of the best restaurants to eat in St. Augustine.

Looking for a Healthy break during your trip to St. Augustine? Read More: Discovering the Benefits of Salt Therapy at the Salt Spa of St. Augustine

Appetizer on table with menu and plates at Catch 27 Restaurant St Augustine

Catch 27

You can’t visit Florida’s Historic Coast and not eat seafood. Catch 27 had some amazing fresh fish to prepare for us and better yet they were more than able to accommodate my Keto requests! I had an amazing grilled snapper served on a bed of zoodles. For more information visit Catch 27’s website here.

Catch 27 dinner with zoodles instead of pasta

Ice Plant

Sometimes you find restaurants by accident. We had planned to have dinner at the Floridian which closes on Tuesday evenings, so instead, we made our way to the Ice Plant which was located around the corner from our Hotel.

Cold beverage on table with blurred bar in background at ice Plant restaurant in St. Agustine.

This modern bar and restaurant was built inside the old St. Augustine ice plant and featured delicious craft cocktails and yummy eats.

Delicious starter at Ice Plant Restaurant

We had a Blue Crab Beignets to start, which our server recommended as the most popular dish. It did not disappoint.

Burger and truffle fries at Ice Plant

I caved and had a burger (without the bun) and some truffle fries for my main. It was delicious, as was this incredible peach dessert we all had to share. For more information visit the Ice Plant website here.

Peach cobbler dessert at Ice Plan St. Augustine

Maple Street Biscuit Company

While this is a chain type restaurant in the Florida area it was an awesome recommendation by our Uber driver for an early breakfast spot. I mean as a Canadian it is always nice to go somewhere that serves real maple syrup with breakfast! I have to confess I caved on Keto that morning when I saw their delicious biscuits on display!

breakfast sandwich with cup of coffee at Maple Street Biscuit Company St Augustine

Swillerbees Craft Donuts & Coffee Bar

I’ll make this easy. If you like donuts, especially handcrafted specialty donuts, then you are going to love Swillerbees. If you are afraid to make the splurge, they have two sizes of donuts so you can get a mini and not feel guilty about it.

Couch Potato Donut at Swillerbees Craft Donuts

They had full size and these little bite donuts. They were all available in some cool flavours including Couch Potato above which was the perfect combination of salty and sweet. 

Grab a donut at Swillerbees in St. Augustine one of your choices for where to eat in St. Augustine Florida.

Hyppo Popsicles

Be sure to grab a Hypo popsicle as you browse the streets of St. Augustine. This became my favourite cold treat during my trip in Florida. These treats are made with real ingredients and available in too many flavours to mention this is a must have on a hot St. Augustine day.

Where to stay in St. Augustine

Tryp by Wyndham St Augustine Review-12 Hilton St. Augustine Florida hotel driveway
 Tryp by Wyndham Hilton
My Review   


Plan a Northeast Florida Roadtrip

Discover more of Northeast Florida just a short1.5-hour drive from Jacksonville Airport!

Disclosure: Travel assistance provided by Air Canada, Florida’s Historic Coast and Visit Florida on a press trip that was part of a 4-day vacation prize package. The opinions expressed in this post are my own.

1 thought on “Where to Eat in St. Augustine Florida”

  1. Lovely post Sharon. This area of Florida is one of my favourites. I eaten at many establishments there but not the ones you reviewed. Can’t wait to go back and try them.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top